Last updated:
Photo: CORRECTION-PAKISTAN-QUAKE - Diariocritico de Venezuela
Pakistan return risk in 2026 stays very high for many groups. Pakistan is a country of more than 240 million people. It has a written constitution and elected courts. However, it also has weak protection against mob violence, religious hate laws, and family-based crimes. This report helps expert witnesses and asylum decision-makers understand who faces real danger if sent back.
The assessment uses reports from the United Nations, Human Rights Watch, the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF), the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), and UK Country Guidance cases. For full background, see the country reports and the asylum guide.
Risk for blasphemy accused returnees
Blasphemy cases registered each year
Honour killings reported each year
Anonymous shelter system for women
Overview of the Risk Picture in Pakistan
Pakistan is rated "Partly Free" by Freedom House and ranks near the bottom on press freedom. The state can run elections and courts. However, it cannot stop mobs, family violence, or religious hate crimes in many cases. In some areas, the police even support the attackers. As a result, Pakistan return risk is high for several clear groups, even if the country is not in open civil war.[1]
Three patterns shape the risk. First, the blasphemy laws (Sections 295-A, 295-B, 295-C of the Penal Code) carry the death penalty. They are often used by mobs and by neighbours in personal disputes. Second, "honour" violence kills women and girls who refuse marriage, marry by choice, or are raped. Third, forced marriage and forced conversion of Hindu and Christian girls happen often, especially in Sindh. In addition, political dissent is now risky after the crackdown on PTI supporters since 2023.[2]
Pakistan also hosts very large internal religious and ethnic tensions. Therefore, internal relocation is rarely safe. Mobs, family networks, and extremist groups reach across all major cities. For asylum cases, this means that the test of "internal flight alternative" usually fails for high-risk groups. The next sections set out the categories most at risk.
Categories at Risk Upon Return to Pakistan
The following groups face documented and serious risk if returned to Pakistan in 2026. Each group has clear evidence of harm in country reports from 2023, 2024, and 2025.
Ahmadiyya Muslims
Ahmadis are declared non-Muslim by the 1974 constitutional amendment. Ordinance XX of 1984 makes it a crime for Ahmadis to "pose as Muslims" or call their places of worship "mosques." They face mob attacks, mosque demolitions, and blasphemy prosecutions. The risk is nationwide and not limited to one region. UK Country Guidance in MN and others (Ahmadis) Pakistan CG [2012] confirmed the risk for openly practising Ahmadis.[3]
Christians and Hindus Accused of Blasphemy
Religious minorities are very over-represented in blasphemy cases. Christians make up about 1.6% of the population but account for around 25% of blasphemy accused. Even an accusation can trigger a mob attack. The 2023 Jaranwala attack saw mobs burn down 21 churches and 80 Christian homes after one accusation. Police often arrive late or join the mob. Therefore, an accused person who returns home faces direct danger from neighbours and from the courts.[4]
Women Fleeing Forced Marriage or Honour Violence
Women who refused a forced marriage, married by choice, or are accused of "dishonouring" the family face the risk of "honour killing." HRCP records over 1,000 honour killings each year, and most cases never reach court. Pakistan has no nationwide network of safe shelters that hide a woman from her family. Dar-ul-Aman shelters often share information with relatives. Consequently, internal relocation is not safe for women fleeing family violence.[5]
PTI Activists and Political Dissidents
Since the arrest of former Prime Minister Imran Khan in 2023, PTI supporters have faced mass arrests, military court trials, and travel bans. Many were charged under anti-terrorism laws after the 9 May 2023 protests. Returnees who were active online or attended protests have been detained at airports. The risk is real but case-specific.[6]
Baloch and Pashtun Activists
Baloch nationalist activists face enforced disappearance by security agencies. The Voice for Baloch Missing Persons records thousands of unsolved cases. Pashtun Tahafuz Movement (PTM) leaders have been detained and shot at. Even peaceful activism in these communities is treated as a security threat. As a result, Baloch and Pashtun activists face high risk on return.[7]
Hazara Shia Muslims
Hazaras in Quetta have been targeted in mass-casualty bombings by Lashkar-e-Jhangvi and the Islamic State Khorasan Province. They live behind walls in two ghettos under armed escort. Travel outside Quetta is dangerous. The state cannot offer real protection. Therefore, Hazaras face a clear risk of serious harm on return.[8]
LGBTQ+ Individuals
Section 377 of the Penal Code, inherited from British India, criminalises same-sex relations with up to life imprisonment. Social punishment is even more severe than legal punishment. Honour killings of gay and trans persons are documented each year. The 2018 Transgender Persons Act offers some legal recognition but does not protect against family or mob violence. As a result, LGBTQ+ Pakistanis face very high return risk.[9]
Hindu and Christian Girls Forced Converted
Each year, around 1,000 Hindu and Christian girls in Sindh are kidnapped, forced to convert to Islam, and forced into marriage with their abductor. Courts often accept a "conversion certificate" from a religious figure and refuse to return the girl to her family. UK Country Guidance has accepted this risk in several recent decisions.[10]
Risk Level by Category — Summary Table
| Category | Risk Level | Primary Risk | Internal Relocation Viable? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ahmadis (open practice) | VERY HIGH | Mob attacks, blasphemy prosecution, demolition of places of worship | No — nationwide laws and TLP networks |
| Christians / Hindus accused of blasphemy | VERY HIGH | Mob killing, lifetime imprisonment, death sentence | No — name and case file follow accused |
| Women fleeing forced marriage / honour | VERY HIGH | Honour killing by family, no anonymous shelter | No — family networks span all cities |
| Hindu / Christian girls (forced conversion targets) | VERY HIGH | Kidnap, forced conversion, forced marriage | No — courts uphold conversion certificates |
| Hazara Shia | HIGH | Targeted bombings, sectarian killings | No — visible ethnicity, ghetto life only |
| LGBTQ+ individuals | VERY HIGH | Section 377, family killing, mob violence | No — risk in all cities |
| Baloch / Pashtun activists | HIGH | Enforced disappearance, extrajudicial killing | No — security databases follow person |
| PTI activists (active profile) | HIGH | Detention, military court, travel ban | Limited — depends on profile |
| Journalists / online critics | HIGH | PECA charges, abduction, beating | Limited — surveillance is national |
Documented Harm to Returnees
The harm to returnees in Pakistan does not always come from the state. Often it comes from family or mobs. However, the result is the same: serious harm or death. The 2023 Jaranwala attacks are the clearest example. After one Christian was accused of insulting the Quran, a mob of thousands burned 21 churches and dozens of homes. Many Christian families fled with nothing.[11]
Furthermore, returnees deported from Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and the UK have reported being held at Karachi or Islamabad airport for hours. Those with PTI links since 2023, or with old blasphemy First Information Reports (FIRs), can be detained on arrival. The Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) keeps a Personal Identification Secure Comparison and Evaluation System (PISCES) database of "suspect" travellers. Anyone whose name is on this list cannot pass through the airport quietly.[12]
Pakistan's blasphemy laws are vague and frequently abused. Accusations alone, even unproven, expose individuals to mob violence, lengthy pretrial detention, and a real risk of death.
USCIRF, Annual Report on Pakistan, 2024
Women returnees face a different but equally serious pattern of harm. A young woman returning to her village after refusing a forced marriage cannot hide. The whole village will know within days. Honour killings often happen in the first weeks. Pakistan's police rarely investigate, and when they do, the family pardon law (qisas and diyat) often allows the killer to walk free. Therefore, the documented harm is severe and well-recorded.[13]
State Protection: Why It Often Fails
Pakistan has a written legal system, a Supreme Court, and a federal police force. On paper, protection exists. In practice, three problems make protection weak for asylum-relevant groups. First, police complicity in blasphemy cases is common. Officers often refuse to file FIRs against the mob and instead arrest the accused for their "own safety." Second, judges face threats from extremist groups. The 2011 killing of judge Pervez Ali Shah, who acquitted a Christian man, scared other judges into refusing such cases.[14]
Third, there is no anonymous shelter system. Government Dar-ul-Aman shelters often allow male relatives to visit and share information with families. Therefore, a woman who runs away from a forced marriage cannot find a long-term safe space inside Pakistan. NGOs like the Aurat Foundation provide some short-term help, but they cannot hide a woman from her family for years. As a result, state protection is not "sufficient" in the legal sense set out in Horvath v Secretary of State [2001] UKHL 37.
Critical: For a person accused of blasphemy in Pakistan, deportation back is direct return to the persecutor. The accused is the named subject of an FIR. The mob and the police both know who they are. There is no safe airport entry, no anonymous city, and no protective custody that lasts longer than a few weeks. Decision-makers who treat Pakistan as a "safe" country in such cases ignore the documented evidence and risk a breach of non-refoulement under Article 33 of the Refugee Convention.
Internal Relocation: Why It Is Rarely Safe
Internal relocation in Pakistan is often suggested by decision-makers as an alternative to international protection. However, the evidence shows that internal relocation rarely works for high-risk groups. Family networks span the country. A young woman from rural Punjab who flees to Karachi will be tracked through cousins, in-laws, and community contacts within weeks. Mobile phone tracing and CNIC (national ID) checkpoints make hiding even harder.[15]
Ahmadis face nationwide discrimination because the constitutional amendment applies in every province. They cannot vote on the main electoral roll without renouncing their faith. The TLP (Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan) has chapters in every major city and organises anti-Ahmadi protests from Karachi to Peshawar. Therefore, an Ahmadi who tries to live openly in a new city faces the same risk as in their home town.
For blasphemy accused, the situation is even worse. The FIR follows the person on the national database. A mob in Lahore can find a man from Faisalabad through social media and informants within days. The 2014 lynching of a Christian couple, Shahzad and Shama Masih, in Kot Radha Kishan happened because a local cleric used a mosque loudspeaker. Such patterns have been repeated dozens of times since. Internal relocation is therefore not a safe option for the great majority of high-risk profiles.[16]
Pakistani Asylum Grant Rates Across Europe
The differences across countries are large. They reflect different approaches to country information rather than different risks. The UK grants Pakistani asylum claims at over 56% at first instance because UK Country Guidance recognises the risk for Ahmadis, blasphemy accused, and women fleeing honour violence. Germany grants only 18% because it tends to apply a wider "internal flight alternative" test. Therefore, the choice of evidence and the careful drafting of the asylum claim matter very much.
UK Country Guidance and Case Law
UK case law sets out clear standards for Pakistan return risk. The leading cases are summarised below. They guide both Home Office decision-makers and the Upper Tribunal.
- MN and others (Ahmadis - country conditions - risk) Pakistan CG [2012] UKUT 389 (IAC): Open practice of Ahmadi faith places a person at real risk of persecution. Internal relocation is not safe for openly practising Ahmadis.
- AW (sufficiency of protection) Pakistan [2011] UKUT 31 (IAC): The state is unable or unwilling to protect women from honour violence in many cases. Sufficiency of protection must be assessed on country evidence, not on the existence of laws on paper.
- SM (lone women - ostracism) Pakistan CG [2016] UKUT 67 (IAC): A lone woman who has separated from her family or husband may face a real risk of persecution and destitution. Internal relocation in Karachi or Lahore is not always reasonable.
- KK and RS (Sur place activities, risk) Sri Lanka CG [2021] UKUT 130 (IAC): Although a Sri Lanka case, the principles on sur place asylum claims are also applied in Pakistan cases.
These cases support a careful, evidence-based approach to Pakistan return risk. Decision-makers should not assume that internal relocation is available simply because Pakistan has many large cities. Instead, the test must be applied to the actual profile of the person, the reach of the persecutor, and the effectiveness of protection.[17]
What This Means for Pakistani Asylum Claims
Pakistani returnees face high risk across several profiles. People accused of blasphemy and religious minorities rely on religion; women at risk of honour crimes or forced marriage fall within a particular social group. Weak protection against mob violence means a written constitution and courts do not amount to effective state protection, and internal relocation is rarely safe where families or accusers can trace the claimant. UK country guidance remains the starting point. Our Pakistan country expert witness reports apply this evidence to individual cases.
Conclusion: HIGH Risk Across Multiple Categories
The Pakistan return risk in 2026 is high or very high for several clear groups: Ahmadis, blasphemy-accused Christians and Hindus, women fleeing forced marriage and honour violence, Hindu and Christian girls forced converted, Hazara Shia, LGBTQ+ persons, Baloch and Pashtun activists, and active PTI dissidents. For all these groups, state protection is weak or absent, and internal relocation rarely works. Therefore, decisions that send such persons back risk a direct breach of non-refoulement.
For asylum lawyers and decision-makers, the key step is to match the individual profile against the country evidence and the case law. A blasphemy accused person sent back to Pakistan faces direct return to the persecutor — the named FIR, the named mob, the named city. For more guidance on building such cases, see the asylum guide and the human rights reports on Pakistan. Expert witness reports from a South Asia specialist can make the difference between a refusal and a grant.
Footnotes
- Freedom House, 'Pakistan: Freedom in the World 2024' (2024); Reporters Without Borders, 'Pakistan Press Freedom Index 2024' (2024)
- Pakistan Penal Code 1860, ss 295-A, 295-B, 295-C; Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, 'State of Human Rights in 2024' (HRCP 2025)
- Constitution of Pakistan, Second Amendment 1974; Ordinance XX of 1984; MN and others (Ahmadis - country conditions - risk) Pakistan CG [2012] UKUT 389 (IAC)
- USCIRF, 'Annual Report 2024: Pakistan' (USCIRF 2024); Human Rights Watch, 'Pakistan: Mob Attack on Christian Community in Jaranwala' (16 August 2023)
- Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, 'State of Human Rights in 2024' (HRCP 2025); UN Women, 'Pakistan Country Brief on Violence against Women' (2024)
- Amnesty International, 'Pakistan: Crackdown on PTI Supporters Following 9 May 2023 Protests' (2024); International Commission of Jurists, 'Pakistan: Military Trials of Civilians' (2024)
- Voice for Baloch Missing Persons, 'Annual Report 2024' (2024); Human Rights Watch, 'Pakistan: Crackdown on Pashtun Tahafuz Movement' (2023)
- Human Rights Watch, 'Pakistan: Hazara Shia Targeted in Quetta' (2023); Minority Rights Group International, 'Pakistan: Hazaras' (2024)
- Pakistan Penal Code 1860, s 377; Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act 2018; ILGA World, 'State-Sponsored Homophobia: Pakistan Chapter' (2024)
- Centre for Social Justice Pakistan, 'Forced Conversions of Hindu and Christian Girls' (2024); USCIRF, 'Forced Conversions in Pakistan' (2023)
- Human Rights Watch, 'Pakistan: Mob Attack in Jaranwala' (16 August 2023); BBC News, 'Pakistan Christian Community Attacks' (17 August 2023)
- Federal Investigation Agency Pakistan, 'PISCES System Overview' (FIA 2023); Dawn newspaper reporting on airport detentions, 2023-2024
- Pakistan Penal Code 1860, ss 299-338 (qisas and diyat); HRCP, 'State of Human Rights 2024' (2025)
- Reuters, 'Pakistani Judge Killed After Acquittal Ruling' (2011); USCIRF, 'Annual Report 2024' (2024)
- National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) Pakistan, CNIC and PISCES integration; HRCP, 'Internal Relocation and Women in Pakistan' (2023)
- BBC News, 'Pakistani Christian Couple Burnt Alive in Kot Radha Kishan' (2014); USCIRF, 'Annual Report 2024' (2024)
- MN and others (Ahmadis) Pakistan CG [2012] UKUT 389 (IAC); AW (sufficiency of protection) Pakistan [2011] UKUT 31 (IAC); SM (lone women) Pakistan CG [2016] UKUT 67 (IAC); Horvath v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2001] UKHL 37
Sources
- Freedom House, Pakistan: Freedom in the World 2024
- Human Rights Watch, World Report 2024: Pakistan
- Reporters Without Borders, Pakistan Press Freedom Profile
- Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, State of Human Rights in 2024 (HRCP 2025)
- Eurostat, Asylum Statistics by Country of Origin 2024
- UK Home Office, Quarterly Immigration Statistics 2024
- Amnesty International, Pakistan Country Page 2024
- Centre for Social Justice Pakistan, Forced Conversions Report 2024
- UK Upper Tribunal Country Guidance cases on Pakistan (2011-2024)
Need an expert witness report for your case?
Our country experts provide independent reports for asylum and immigration cases in the UK, US, Canada, and EU.
Order an expert witness report |
Find a country expert witness |
About our expert team