Human Rights Experts · https://thehuman-rights.com/gender-based-asylum-claims-expert-report/
Asylum Evidence & Documentation Asylum Guide Expert Witness Reports Explained Women's Rights

Gender-Based Asylum Claims: What to Ask a Country Expert

Gender-Based Asylum Claims: What to Ask a Country Expert

Last updated:

Photo: Gender Abolition - Kristofher Muñoz

In gender-based asylum claims, a country expert report often decides whether the judge accepts that the state cannot protect the client. It can also show whether a woman could really live alone in another city. However, the report is only as good as the letter of instruction. Vague questions produce long background chapters that judges ignore. In contrast, precise questions tied to the refusal letter produce answers that a judge can quote.

Running an asylum case in a UK tribunal or a US immigration court? We prepare the independent country evidence it rests on.Find a country expert

This guide explains what to ask a country expert in gender-based asylum claims. It covers domestic violence, honour-based violence, female genital mutilation (FGM), forced marriage, trafficking and sexual violence. It also covers LGBT+ claims where gender norms drive the risk. We list the documents to send, the questions to avoid and the rules in the UK and the US. The law itself sits in our guide to the legal framework for gender persecution, so we do not repeat it here. Last reviewed: 21 October 2026.

230M+
Women and girls alive today who have undergone FGM (UNICEF, 2024)
20 pages
Maximum length of a UK expert report without permission
7
Expert duties listed by the Upper Tribunal in MOJ (Somalia)
2025
Year the BIA and Attorney General narrowed US sex-based and domestic violence groups
Sources: UNICEF (8 March 2024); FtT (IAC) Practice Direction (1 November 2024) para 9.2; MOJ & Ors (Return to Mogadishu) Somalia CG [2014] UKUT 00442 (IAC); Matter of K-E-S-G- and Matter of S-S-F-M- (2025)

What a country expert adds in gender-based asylum claims

Most gender-based asylum claims involve a non-state persecutor. It may be a husband, a father, an in-law family or a trafficking network. As a result, the hard questions usually concern the future. Judges need to know whether the police would act and whether the family could find her. They also need to know whether she could rent a flat, work and register her children without a male relative.

In Shah and Islam, the House of Lords accepted that a state's failure to protect women can supply the link to a Convention reason. Later, in Fornah, it held that women at risk of FGM in Sierra Leone formed a particular social group.[1] Both cases turned on evidence about how a society treats women. A country expert supplies that evidence for the client's region, ethnic group and family. For the group question itself, see our guide to the particular social group.

In the UK, section 33 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022 sets two conditions for a social group. Members must share a protected characteristic. In addition, the group must have a "distinct identity" because the surrounding society sees it as different.[2] That second limb is a factual question about social perception. Therefore, it suits the expert well.

Before the letter: issues, documents and adverse material

Start with the refusal letter or the review. List each disputed issue in one line, for example "sufficiency of protection in Lahore". In the UK, the letter of instruction must state the disputed issues and goes into the report as an attachment.[3] The judge will therefore read it.

Next, send the full file. In MOJ, the Upper Tribunal said lawyers must give the expert all relevant material. This includes material "adverse to the client's case".[4] A report written without the interview record loses weight as soon as the Home Office points this out. In practice, send at least:

  • the screening and substantive interview records;
  • all witness statements and addendum statements;
  • the refusal letter, the review or the DHS position, and any earlier decision;
  • medical, psychiatric or psychological reports, including any Istanbul Protocol report;
  • home-country documents, such as police reports, court papers and marriage, divorce or birth records;
  • a short chronology and the list of disputed issues.

Finally, check consent and safety. For example, gender claims often include details of rape, abortion or sexuality that the family does not know. Tell the expert if anyone in the home country must not learn about the claim. This matters when the expert contacts local sources.

Questions to put to the expert, by issue

Good questions name the client's profile, the place and the period. For example, "a divorced Pashtun woman, aged 34, with two daughters, returning to Peshawar" is a profile. "Women in Pakistan" is not. The issues below arise most often in gender-based asylum claims.

State protection in practice

Ask how the law works in practice, not only what it says. The Home Office's own guidance lists the failures to look for. These include marital rape exemptions, no police response and a refusal to prosecute. The guidance also accepts that in some societies a woman cannot approach the police without a male relative.[5] So ask about police responses, conviction rates and protection orders. Ask also where shelters are and who may stay in them. In Pakistan, for instance, the Upper Tribunal found that women in shelters with boys over five face separation from their sons.[6]

The persecutor's reach and links to officials

Ask whether a person with the persecutor's profile could trace the client in another area. Relevant facts include tribal or clan networks, links to police or armed groups, and access to registration databases. Furthermore, ask how families find women who have fled. Common routes are relatives, mobile phones and school records of children.

Social attitudes and family structures

Ask how her community would view the client now. This covers the wider family, tribal or jirga decisions and whether male relatives can act for her. Our short video below explains what Taliban rules mean for a woman in Afghanistan today. That is the kind of context a judge needs.

Internal relocation for a lone woman or a mother

Relocation is often the decisive issue in gender-based asylum claims. The Home Office guidance says divorced women, widows and single parents may face particular difficulties. This is "especially" so where women "are expected to have male protection".[5] Therefore, ask about renting without a male guarantor, work, childcare, identity papers and schooling. In Afghanistan, for example, women need a mahram (male guardian) to use public transport and to access services.[7]

Honour codes and whether a dispute ends

In honour cases, ask what the code requires and who enforces it. Above all, ask whether the dispute ever ends. It may end through time, payment, mediation or a death. Similarly, ask whether a new partner, a child born outside marriage or a known asylum claim would revive it.

FGM: prevalence, ethnic group and pressure on daughters

National FGM figures hide large differences. In K and others (FGM) The Gambia, the Upper Tribunal assessed risk by the ethnic group of the father. For a married woman, it looked at the husband's group.[8] So ask for prevalence by region and ethnic group, using survey data such as DHS or MICS. Ask also about the usual age at cutting and about re-cutting after childbirth. Finally, ask whether grandmothers or in-laws decide, and whether parents can refuse in practice.

Trafficking and the risk of re-trafficking

For Albania, the country guidance gives a ready framework. In TD and AD, the Tribunal said that "re-trafficking is a reality". It then listed risk factors such as the family's social and economic standing, education, mental health, an illegitimate child, home area, age and support network.[9] Ask the expert, therefore, to address each factor for the client. Ask also how long shelter support lasts and what happens afterwards. Earlier, SB (Moldova) accepted former victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation as a social group.[10] In August 2026, the Tribunal also gave guidance on male victims from Albania.[11]

Stigma of divorce, rape and children born outside marriage

Ask how landlords, employers and officials treat a divorced woman or a rape survivor. Ask the same about a mother of a child born outside marriage. Also ask whether that status shows on birth records or identity papers. These answers often explain why a client did not report abuse.

What not to ask the expert

Do not ask the expert whether the client is credible. In gender-based asylum claims, as in any other, credibility is for the judge. However, an expert can say whether an account is plausible and consistent with known conditions. In Mibanga, the Court of Appeal accepted that expert evidence gives the context for the judge's assessment.[12]

Similarly, do not ask for legal conclusions. The Center for Gender & Refugee Studies (CGRS) warns experts against saying that "Y is a particular social group". It also warns against saying relocation is "neither safe nor reasonable". Such statements can reduce the weight of the expert's real knowledge.[13] Instead, ask for the facts the judge needs. Finally, do not ask a country expert about scars, trauma or memory. Those questions belong to a clinician.

Working alongside medical and psychological experts

Many gender-based asylum claims need two experts. The country expert explains the risk on return. Meanwhile, the clinician explains injuries, trauma and its effect on memory. The UN revised the Istanbul Protocol in 2022. It sets the standard for medical and psychological evidence of torture, including sexual violence.[14] Our guide to medical evidence and the Istanbul Protocol covers that report.

Tell each expert what the other is covering. In this way, you avoid gaps and contradictions. For example, a psychiatrist may explain why the client disclosed rape late. The country expert can then explain the stigma that kept her silent. Notably, the Home Office accepts that late disclosure "should not automatically count against" credibility.[5]

Gender also affects how evidence is gathered. Under Home Office guidance, a claimant may ask for a male or female interviewer and interpreter.[5] At the appeal, the Tribunal must consider the Joint Presidential Guidance Note No 2 of 2010 on vulnerable witnesses.[15] Likewise, if the expert needs to speak to the client, ask whether she prefers a woman. CGRS notes that a survivor may find it hard to talk to a male expert from her own region.[13]

UK and US rules that shape the instructions

United Kingdom

In the First-tier Tribunal, the Practice Direction of 1 November 2024 limits expert reports to 20 pages without permission. The report must focus on the disputed issues and include a statement of truth.[3] In addition, ask the expert to confirm that they have read paragraphs 23 to 27 of MOJ. The Tribunal asked for this in MS (Pakistan).[16]

Country guidance (CG) also shapes the questions, because a CG decision is authoritative on its issue.[3] So name the relevant CG case, such as KA and Others for Pakistan or TD and AD for Albania. Then ask whether conditions have changed and whether the client fits its findings. The Home Office's gender issues guidance of 2018 remains the current version. Consequently, the expert can test the refusal against it.[5]

United States

The US position changed sharply in 2025. In Matter of K-E-S-G-, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) rejected groups defined only by sex, or by sex and nationality. It called them "overbroad and insufficiently particular".[17] Then, in Matter of S-S-F-M-, the Attorney General restored Matter of A-B- and overruled Matter of A-R-C-G-.[18] In 2026, Matter of V-A-B- rejected the group "married Mexican women who are unable to leave their relationship" as circular.[19]

As a result, US instructions need sharper evidence. Ask how society sets the proposed group apart. Ask also about state involvement or acquiescence, and any political or religious dimension. In Matter of Kasinga, the BIA recognised FGM as persecution.[20] On weight, Matter of J-G-T- admits most expert evidence. However, two 2026 decisions cut weight where opinions rest on anecdote or ignore contrary evidence.[21] Our article on what a judge reads first in an expert report covers these rules.

Point UK tribunal US immigration court
Letter of instruction Attached, with disputed issues (PD 9.3(d)) Not required; list documents relied on
Length 20 pages unless permitted No fixed limit
Group evidence Distinct identity, NABA s 33(4) Social distinction and particularity
Domestic violence Protection and relocation, CG cases A-B- standards restored in 2025
Expert duties MOJ paras 23 to 27; statement of truth J-G-T-, G-M-I-, D-J-L-
Table 1: How UK and US rules shape instructions in gender-based asylum claims

Typical refusal points and how the expert answers them

Refusals in gender-based asylum claims repeat the same points. Each one maps to a question for the expert.

Refusal point What to ask the expert
The state has laws against abuse Compare the law with police practice and conviction data in her region
She can move to the capital Housing, work and registration for her profile; reliance on male relatives
The family has lost interest Whether such honour disputes fade, and what revives them
The parents oppose FGM The role of the wider family and the father's ethnic group
She can stay in a shelter Length of stay and life after leaving, as in KA and TD and AD
The account is implausible Whether events fit known patterns of forced marriage or recruitment
Table 2: Common refusal points and the matching expert question

Model instruction questions for gender-based asylum claims

Adapt these questions to the client and the refusal. In most cases, five to eight questions fit within the 20-page limit.

  1. Is the account at [AIR/WS paragraphs] plausible and consistent with conditions in [region]?
  2. How do police and courts in [area] respond when a woman like the client reports [harm]?
  3. Could [persecutor] trace her in [relocation area] through family, officials or registration?
  4. What would a [single/divorced] woman with [children] face in [area] in housing, work and registration?
  5. What shelters exist, who may stay, for how long, and what happens on leaving?
  6. How would her community view [divorce/rape/a child born outside marriage]?
  7. For FGM: what is the prevalence for [ethnic group] in [region], and can parents refuse?
  8. For trafficking: how do the TD and AD factors apply, and what is the re-trafficking risk?

UK variant: ask the expert to address [CG case] and the relevant CPIN. Ask also for confirmation that they have read MOJ paragraphs 23 to 27, and for the paragraph 9.4 statement of truth.

US variant: ask how society in [country] sets apart [proposed group]. Then ask whether state actors take part in or tolerate the harm. Finally, ask the expert to explain any disagreement with the State Department report.

Checklist before you send the instructions

Before sending instructions in gender-based asylum claims, check each point below.

  • Disputed issues listed from the refusal or review
  • Full profile stated: age, region, ethnic group, marital status, children
  • Full file sent, including adverse material and medical reports
  • CG case and CPIN named (UK), or State Department report (US)
  • No questions on credibility or legal conclusions
  • Safety limits for in-country enquiries explained
  • Preference for a female expert or interpreter checked
  • Time left for an addendum if the Home Office or DHS replies

Common questions

Do we need a country expert if there is a CG case?

Often, yes. A CG case gives the general picture. The expert then applies it to the client and checks for later changes.

Should the expert meet the client?

Not always. A desk-based report is usually enough. However, a short meeting can help where ethnicity or tribal origin is disputed.

Can one expert cover country conditions and trauma?

Rarely. Each expert must stay within their own field. So instruct a clinician for medical and psychological issues.

Where to get help

Clients should first get advice from a solicitor or regulated adviser. In the US, that means an immigration attorney or accredited representative. Representatives handling gender-based asylum claims can find an expert witness for the country and issue. Send draft questions early, so the expert can flag gaps before work starts.

Conclusion

In gender-based asylum claims, the country expert answers questions the papers cannot. These include whether the police would act, whether the persecutor could find her and whether she could live alone elsewhere. Therefore, the letter of instruction should state the client's profile, list the disputed issues and attach the full file. It should also avoid questions on credibility and legal conclusions. In the UK, the 2024 Practice Direction, MOJ and the relevant CG case set the frame. In the US, K-E-S-G-, S-S-F-M- and V-A-B- make expert evidence on social distinction and state protection even more important.


Footnotes

  1. R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, ex p Shah; Islam v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1999] 2 AC 629 (HL); Secretary of State for the Home Department v K; Fornah v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2006] UKHL 46, [2007] 1 AC 412.
  2. Nationality and Borders Act 2022, s 33(2)–(4).
  3. Senior President of Tribunals, 'Practice Direction of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal' (1 November 2024) paras 9.1–9.4, 10.1–10.6.
  4. MOJ & Ors (Return to Mogadishu) Somalia CG [2014] UKUT 00442 (IAC), paras 23–27.
  5. Home Office, 'Gender issues in the asylum claim' (version 3.0, published for Home Office staff 10 April 2018), sections 'Sufficiency of protection', 'Internal relocation', 'Requests for a male or female interviewer or interpreter' and 'Credibility and gender issues'.
  6. KA and Others (domestic violence – risk on return) Pakistan CG [2010] UKUT 216 (IAC), headnote; see also SM (lone women – ostracism) Pakistan CG [2016] UKUT 67 (IAC).
  7. Home Office, 'Country Policy and Information Note: Afghanistan: Fear of the Taliban' (version 6.0, February 2026) paras 8.2.8, 8.3.4, citing UNAMA reporting on the 2024 Law on the Propagation of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice.
  8. K and others (FGM) The Gambia CG [2013] UKUT 00062 (IAC), headnote.
  9. TD and AD (Trafficked women) CG [2016] UKUT 00092 (IAC), headnote paras (e)–(h), maintaining and amending AM and BM (Trafficked women) Albania CG [2010] UKUT 00080 (IAC).
  10. SB (PSG – Protection Regulations – Reg 6) Moldova CG [2008] UKAIT 00002, headnote para 4.
  11. LR (Male VOTs) Albania CG [2026] UKUT 00315 (IAC) (issued 13 August 2026).
  12. Mibanga v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] EWCA Civ 367, para 24 (Wilson J).
  13. Center for Gender & Refugee Studies, 'Best Practices for Expert Witnesses in Asylum and Related Claims' (Practice Advisory, December 2025) 27–28, 39–40 and Appendix G.
  14. OHCHR, 'Istanbul Protocol: Manual on the Effective Investigation and Documentation of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment' (Professional Training Series No 8/Rev.2, 2022).
  15. Practice Direction (1 November 2024) para 13.1; Joint Presidential Guidance Note No 2 of 2010: Child, Vulnerable Adult and Sensitive Appellant Guidance (30 October 2010); AM (Afghanistan) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2017] EWCA Civ 1123, para 30.
  16. MS (Trafficking – Tribunal's Powers – Art 4 ECHR) Pakistan [2016] UKUT 00226 (IAC), para 69.
  17. Matter of K-E-S-G-, 29 I&N Dec 145 (BIA 2025), headnote.
  18. Matter of S-S-F-M-, 29 I&N Dec 207 (AG 2025), restoring Matter of A-B-, 27 I&N Dec 316 (AG 2018) and Matter of A-B-, 28 I&N Dec 199 (AG 2021), and overruling Matter of A-B-, 28 I&N Dec 307 (AG 2021) and Matter of A-R-C-G-, 26 I&N Dec 388 (BIA 2014).
  19. Matter of V-A-B-, 29 I&N Dec 621 (BIA 2026), headnote.
  20. Matter of Kasinga, 21 I&N Dec 357 (BIA 1996).
  21. Matter of J-G-T-, 28 I&N Dec 97 (BIA 2020); Matter of G-M-I-, 29 I&N Dec 431 (BIA 2026); Matter of D-J-L-, 29 I&N Dec 485 (BIA 2026).

Sources

  1. Senior President of Tribunals, Practice Direction of the Immigration and Asylum Chamber of the First-tier Tribunal, 1 November 2024
  2. Home Office, Gender issues in the asylum claim, version 3.0, April 2018
  3. Courts and Tribunals Judiciary, Joint FtTIAC and UTIAC Presidential Guidance
  4. The National Archives, KA and Others (domestic violence – risk on return) Pakistan CG [2010] UKUT 216 (IAC)
  5. Tribunal decisions, TD and AD (Trafficked women) CG [2016] UKUT 00092 (IAC)
  6. Tribunal decisions, K and others (FGM) The Gambia CG [2013] UKUT 00062 (IAC)
  7. Tribunal decisions, SB (PSG – Protection Regulations – Reg 6) Moldova CG [2008] UKAIT 00002
  8. Tribunal decisions, LR (Male VOTs) Albania CG [2026] UKUT 00315 (IAC), August 2026
  9. legislation.gov.uk, Nationality and Borders Act 2022, section 33
  10. US Department of Justice, EOIR, Agency Decisions, Volume 29 (K-E-S-G-, S-S-F-M-, V-A-B-, G-M-I-, D-J-L-)
  11. UNICEF, Over 230 million girls and women alive today have been subjected to female genital mutilation, 8 March 2024
  12. Center for Gender & Refugee Studies, Best Practices for Expert Witnesses in Asylum and Related Claims, Practice Advisory, December 2025
  13. Home Office, Country Policy and Information Note: Afghanistan: Fear of the Taliban, version 6.0, February 2026
  14. OHCHR, Istanbul Protocol (Professional Training Series No 8/Rev.2), 2022

Need an expert witness report for your case?

Our country experts provide independent reports for asylum and immigration cases in the UK, US, Canada, and EU.
Order an expert witness report  |  Find a country expert witness  |  About our expert team

Share this article: 𝕏 f in ☎

Frequently asked questions

What does this mean in a hearing?

Most gender-based asylum claims involve a non-state persecutor. It may be a husband, a father, an in-law family or a trafficking network. As a result, the hard questions usually concern the future. Judges need to know whether the police would act and whether the family could find her.

How is this tested by a tribunal?

Do not ask the expert whether the client is credible. In gender-based asylum claims, as in any other, credibility is for the judge. However, an expert can say whether an account is plausible and consistent with known conditions. In Mibanga, the Court of Appeal accepted that expert evidence gives the context for the judge's assessment.

Which groups does this affect most?

Adapt these questions to the client and the refusal. In most cases, five to eight questions fit within the 20-page limit.

Human rights documentation photo
Human Rights Experts
Expert witness reports and country condition analysis for asylum and human rights cases worldwide.
Stay Informed
Subscribe to receive the latest human rights news, expert analysis, and country condition updates.
© 2026 Human Rights Experts. All Rights Reserved.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram